Possible other marriages to Martha Pennington Dille, dgtr of Nehemiah and Betsey Dille, in 1841, and Isabel McIlrath, dgtr of Alexander and Rhoda Condit McIlrath (both of these marriages occurred in Cuyahoga County, Ohio). Another possibility is that Benjamin had a son of the same name and it was HE that married Martha. She was born in 1824. Isabel McIlrath was probably born at least a decade or two earlier.

He was married to Mary M. (surname unknown) during the 1840's as her name appears on several property deeds as his wife.

1. Lewis SAWTELL b. Abt 1838, ,, Ohio; d. 23 Dec 1861, Brooklyn, Cuyahoga, Ohio.
2. Emily SAWTELL b. 27 Oct 1841, Brooklyn, Cuyahoga, Ohio; d. 23 Oct 1895, , Cuyahoga, Ohio.
3. Edward H. SAWTELL b. Abt 1843, ,, Ohio.

OBIT: Id#: 0310959
Name: Sawtell, James Sr.
Date: July 6, 1852
Source: Source unknown; Cleveland Necrology File, Reel #071.
Notes: Sawtell- In Brooklyn on Thursday, July 1, James Sawtell, Sr., aged 67 years. Mr. Sawtell was an old and esteemed citizen He was in early life a resident of Auburn N. Y. and came to Ohio in 1815 since which time he has been a resident of this State. and for the last thirty years near this city. Vermont papers please copy. 1785-1852. Dennison Cemetery Cleveland, Ohio.

OBIT: Name: Sawtell, Mrs. Susanna
Date: July 9, 1852
Source: Source unknown; Cleveland Necrology File, Reel #071.
Notes: Sawtell- In Brooklyn, on the 7th inst., Mrs. Susanna Sawtell, aged 65 years. Also in this city on the 8th inst., Mr. Ira Sawtell, aged 43 years. Mr. Sawtell leaves an interesting family to mourn his loss.

1. James SAWTELL, Jr. b. Abt 1814; d. 12 Jul 1852, , Cuyahoga, Ohio.
2. 1. Benjamin SAWTELL b. Abt 1805, ,, New York; d. Jan 1851, Brooklyn, Cuyahoga, Ohio.
3. Levi L. SAWTELL
4. Ira SAWTELL d. Bef 1860.