| Children |
| | 1. Sophie FAY, b. 17 May 1800, Sturbridge,, Massachusetts  |
| > | 2. Asa FAY, b. 23 Oct 1801, Sturbridge,, Massachusetts  |
| | 3. Amanda FAY, b. 20 Nov 1802, Sturbridge,, Massachusetts  |
| > | 4. Benajah FAY, Jr., b. 6 Aug 1806, Sturbridge,, Massachusetts  |
| | 5. Joseph Mason FAY, b. 31 Jul 1805, Sturbridge,, Massachusetts  |
| | 6. Mary FAY, b. 31 Jul 1808, Sturbridge,, Massachusetts  |
| | 7. Harriet FAY, b. 27 Apr 1810, Sturbridge,, Massachusetts  |
| | 8. Huldah FAY, b. 19 Nov 1811, Sturbridge,, Massachusetts  |
| | 9. Watson FAY, b. 26 Sep 1813, Sturbridge,, Massachusetts  |
| | 10. Lyman FAY, b. 6 Oct 1815, Sturbridge,, Massachusetts  |
|